Short answer
Not necessarily. Many dealers send body work to outside shops anyway, and New York law lets you choose any shop, whatever your insurer suggests. For Queens drivers, what matters is a repair that follows the car maker's procedures, the parts you agree on, matched paint, and a shop close enough that the repair fits your week.
The choice is yours in New York
Our general answer, is it better to go to a dealership for body work, weighs dealers against independent shops in detail. The New York part is simple: under section 2610 of the New York Insurance Law, your insurer cannot require you to use a particular shop. That applies to the dealer, the insurer's own list, or an independent shop in your neighborhood. Our insurance claims page explains how the rule works.
Under US federal law, a car maker also cannot void the factory warranty just because the repair was done somewhere other than its dealer.
What matters more than the sign
Whichever you call, ask the same things:
- Procedures. Will the repair follow the car maker's published procedures for your model?
- Parts. New from the car maker, new from another maker, or used? Agree before work starts.
- Paint. Will the color be tinted and blended to your car?
- Structure. Will frame or unibody damage be measured, not judged by eye?
- Sensors. Will cameras and radar be calibrated after a bumper or windshield repair?
- Registration. New York repair shops must be registered with the DMV. Any shop, dealer or not, should be able to show you.
The Queens angle: distance and the claim
If you bought the car in another borough, on Long Island or out of state, taking it back to that dealer can mean a long trip on the LIE or the Grand Central with a car that may not be fit for it, and another long trip to check on the job or collect it.
A shop in the borough makes the in between steps easier: dropping the car off, looking at hidden damage when the shop calls, signing a supplement, picking up the keys. The shop is in Forest Hills, and the M and R trains stop at 63rd Drive and 67th Avenue on Queens Boulevard if you are heading home without the car.
The other half is the claim. A dealer's service desk may leave you to deal with the insurer. When we take a job, we work with your insurance company and handle the claim, from the estimate to the finished repair.
For a full checklist on choosing any shop, see where is the best place to get my car repaired in Queens. The whole repair process is in our collision repair guide, and the Queens area page has directions and the neighborhoods we see cars from.
More questions drivers ask
- What does collision repair mean?
- What's the difference between a collision shop and a body shop?
- What are the most common auto body repairs?
- What is the role of an auto body technician?
- Can body shops fix mechanical issues?
- Where is the best place to get my car repaired?
- Is it better to go to a dealership for body work?
- How much do collision repairs usually cost?
- Do you pay before or after collision repair?
- How long does it take to repair collision damage?
- Is bumper replacement covered by insurance?
- Does car insurance cover hitting a deer?
- Should I have collision insurance on a 10 year old car?