Short answer
Usually after. On an insurance claim, the insurer pays its share once the repair is approved, either to the shop or to you, and you pay your deductible, if one applies, when you collect the car. On a repair you pay for yourself, the price is agreed first and settled at pickup, though some shops ask for a parts deposit.
How the money moves on an insurance claim
Once the estimate is written, the insurer reviews it, often with its own appraiser, and approves the repair. From there the payment can go two ways.
- Paid to the shop. Many insurers pay the shop directly for the approved repair. You only deal with your share.
- Paid to you. Some insurers send the check to the policyholder. If the car is financed or leased, the check may carry the lender's name as well, and you may need their sign off before it can be used for the repair.
If hidden damage turns up once the car is apart, the shop sends a supplement to the insurer, and a second payment covers the extra work once it is approved.
Where the deductible fits
On a claim against your own collision or comprehensive coverage, the deductible is the part you pay. It is usually paid to the shop when you collect the car, and the insurer pays the rest of the approved repair. If the other driver's insurer is paying under their liability coverage, there is normally no deductible for you.
Paying for a repair yourself
Some drivers skip insurance for small repairs. In that case you agree the price with the shop from a written estimate before work starts. Payment is usually due at pickup. A shop may ask for a deposit when parts have to be ordered, so ask up front.
Before you sign anything
Most shops ask you to sign a repair authorization before they start. Read what it covers. Ask when payment is due, what happens if hidden damage is found, and who you pay. A clear answer now saves an argument at the counter. For what drives the size of the bill, see how much collision repairs usually cost, and for why the timeline can move, how long it takes to repair collision damage.
Our insurance claims page covers the claim side in more detail, and the collision repair guide walks through the whole process.
Driving in Queens? See do you pay before or after collision repair in Queens for New York estimate rules and local examples.
More questions drivers ask
- What does collision repair mean?
- What's the difference between a collision shop and a body shop?
- What are the most common auto body repairs?
- What is the role of an auto body technician?
- Can body shops fix mechanical issues?
- Where is the best place to get my car repaired?
- Is it better to go to a dealership for body work?
- How much do collision repairs usually cost?
- How long does it take to repair collision damage?
- Is bumper replacement covered by insurance?
- Does car insurance cover hitting a deer?
- Should I have collision insurance on a 10 year old car?