Short answer
The best place is a shop you choose, not one you are steered to. Look for a free written estimate before work starts, photos of the damage, a clear list of the parts being used, experience with your kind of repair, honest reviews, and a shop that handles the insurance claim so you are not stuck in the middle.
You get to choose
After a crash, your insurer may hand you a list of shops it works with. You do not have to use one. You can pick your own shop, whatever the insurance list says, and the insurer still has to work with the shop you choose. Our insurance claims page explains how that works in New York.
Questions to ask any shop
These work whether you are calling one shop or five.
- Is the estimate free, and is it written? You should see what is being fixed before any work starts.
- Will you photograph and document hidden damage? Most crashes hide something behind the bumper. A shop that never finds anything is probably not looking.
- Will you deal with my insurer? Estimates, supplements and approvals go back and forth. A shop that handles the claim saves you hours on the phone.
- What parts will you use? New parts from the car maker, new parts from other makers, or used parts. Your policy often decides, but you are allowed to ask.
- Is structural damage measured? Frame and unibody damage should be measured against the maker's dimensions, not judged by eye.
- Can you do the whole job? Body, frame, glass and paint in one place means the car is not passed between specialists while the claim is open.
- When can I reach you? Accidents keep no schedule.
Reading reviews the right way
Star ratings say less than the reviews behind them. Look for reviews that describe a repair like yours, mention how the shop dealt with the insurer, and say how the car looked weeks later. Read how the shop answers complaints, too. Our reviews page has more on judging any body shop's reviews.
Dealership or independent?
Some drivers assume the dealer is the safe choice. Often the dealer sends body work out anyway. The trade offs are set out in dealership vs body shop, and collision shop vs body shop explains what the name over the door tells you. For the whole process, see our collision repair guide.
Driving in Queens? See where is the best place to get my car repaired in Queens for New York shop rules and what to ask locally.
More questions drivers ask
- What does collision repair mean?
- What's the difference between a collision shop and a body shop?
- What are the most common auto body repairs?
- What is the role of an auto body technician?
- Can body shops fix mechanical issues?
- Is it better to go to a dealership for body work?
- How much do collision repairs usually cost?
- Do you pay before or after collision repair?
- How long does it take to repair collision damage?
- Is bumper replacement covered by insurance?
- Does car insurance cover hitting a deer?
- Should I have collision insurance on a 10 year old car?