Collision repair answers

Should I have collision insurance on a 10 year old car?

Short answer

It depends on what the car is worth and whether you could afford to repair or replace it yourself. A commonly cited rule of thumb says to rethink collision coverage once its yearly cost plus your deductible gets close to the car's value. If the car is financed or leased, the lender will usually require it, whatever its age.

What collision coverage pays for

Collision coverage pays to repair your own car after you hit another car or an object, or roll it, minus your deductible. It is what pays when the crash was your fault, or when the other driver cannot be identified or found. If the other driver caused the crash, their property damage liability is supposed to pay for your car instead, with or without your collision coverage.

In New York, collision coverage is optional. The coverage the state requires is liability, no-fault personal injury protection and uninsured motorist coverage. Comprehensive, which pays for theft, storms, vandalism and animal strikes, is optional too.

The rule of thumb, and its limits

A version you will often hear is the 10 percent rule: if a year of collision coverage costs more than about a tenth of the car's value, dropping it may make sense. Another way to look at it is to add a year's collision cost to your deductible and compare the total with what the insurer would pay if the car were written off, which is roughly its market value.

These are starting points, not answers. Age alone does not decide it. A well kept 10 year old car can still be worth a lot, and some models hold their value well.

Questions to ask yourself

What you keep if you drop it

You keep the required coverages, so injuries and damage you cause to others are still covered. You can also keep comprehensive on its own with many insurers, which still covers things like a deer strike. See does car insurance cover hitting a deer. Damage someone else causes is still claimed against their insurance, as explained in is bumper replacement covered by insurance. For how a claim runs from start to finish, see our collision repair guide.