Insurance claims

Insurance Claims: You Choose the Body Shop

Your insurer may hand you a list of shops. You are not stuck with it. Bring the car to us and we work with your insurance company and handle the claim, from the first estimate to the finished repair.

The list is a suggestion, not a rule

After a crash, many insurers point you toward their preferred shops, sometimes called a direct repair program. Those shops have an agreement with the insurer. That can be convenient, but it is the insurer's arrangement, not a requirement for you.

Section 2610 of the New York Insurance Law says an insurer cannot require that your car be repaired at a particular shop. You can pick your own, whatever the insurance list says. The insurer still inspects the damage and agrees the cost of the repair, but where the car goes is your decision.

Choose us and the paperwork comes with it. We work with your insurance company and handle the claim, so you are not stuck relaying messages between an adjuster and a shop.

How a claim usually runs

Every insurer has its own forms, but most claims follow the same stops. Only the first and the last need much from you.

  1. Report

    Tell your insurer about the accident and get a claim number. Call us too, any time.

  2. Estimate

    We look the damage over and write a free estimate before any work starts.

  3. Inspect

    The insurer's appraiser or adjuster reviews the damage and the estimate.

  4. Approve

    The insurer agrees the repair. Extra damage found later goes back as a supplement.

  5. Repair

    Body, frame, glass and paint get fixed in one shop.

  6. Pickup

    You pay any deductible your policy has, get your keys back and drive away.

What to have ready when you call

None of this is needed to get started, but each one makes the claim move faster.

  • Your policy and claim number

    The policy number is on your insurance card. The claim number comes from your insurer once you report the accident.

  • The other driver's details

    Name, phone, plate number and insurance company. A photo of their insurance card saves typing it out.

  • Photos from the scene

    Both cars, the plates, the street and any skid marks or debris. Take more than you think you need.

  • The police report number

    If police came to the scene, ask for the report number before you leave.

  • Your MV-104, if you need one

    New York requires an accident report to the DMV within 10 days if anyone was hurt or damage to any one person's property is over $1,000.

  • Notes while they are fresh

    Time, place, direction of travel and what happened. Memory fades quickly after a crash.

Deductibles, supplements and the final bill

Three things confuse most drivers during a claim.

The deductible. If you claim on your own collision coverage, your policy deductible is usually yours to pay, and the insurer covers the rest of the approved repair. If the other driver was at fault and their insurer accepts it, the repair is normally paid by their property damage coverage instead.

The supplement. The first estimate is written from what can be seen. When the bumper and trim come off and a cracked bracket or bent support turns up, the shop documents it and asks the insurer to approve a supplement. This is routine, and it is how hidden damage gets paid for instead of left in the car.

The parts. Your policy can affect which kind of replacement parts the insurer pays for. If that matters to you, ask about it before the repair starts. Our collision repair page explains how repair or replace decisions get made.

You can pick your own shop, whatever the insurance list says.

Bring the car to us and we deal with the insurer, the estimate and the claim. You deal with getting on with your week.

  • Claim handled

    We work with your insurance company and handle the claim for you.

  • Free estimate

    We price the damage before any work starts.

  • Open 24 hours

    Call 646-347-5520 the minute it happens.

When the other driver was at fault

You can claim on the other driver's insurance instead of your own. Their insurer will want to investigate and may take longer to accept the claim, but if they do, the repair is paid from their policy and you normally owe no deductible. You still choose the shop.

Whichever way the claim goes, the next step is the same: call us or send the details. If you are in Queens, the shop is in Forest Hills, close to home. You can also read what other drivers have said on our reviews page.

Claims look different depending on the damage. A crash claim usually runs through collision repair and, when the structure is hit, frame repair. Hail and a cracked windshield are often claimed on comprehensive coverage instead, which is covered on the hail damage repair and auto glass repair pages. Drivers from Brooklyn, Manhattan and Long Island can bring a claim to the same shop.

New York insurance and report questions

Two questions come up before almost every claim. Which coverage you carry decides who pays for the repair, and what car insurance is required in NY explains the three coverages every New York car must have and what is optional. Insurers often ask for the police report too, and how do I get a copy of an accident report in NYS explains where to get one.

Insurance answers

New York claim questions,answered.

Coverage rules and paperwork for New York drivers, in plain words.

Insurance claim questions

Can my insurance company make me use its shop?

No. New York insurance law says an insurer cannot require you to have your car repaired at a particular shop. The insurer can recommend shops, but the choice is yours.

Do I call my insurer first or the body shop first?

Either works. Many drivers call their insurer to open the claim and get a claim number, then call us. If you call us first, we can tell you what the insurer will ask for. The number is 646-347-5520, any time.

What if the shop finds more damage once the car is apart?

That is common. The extra damage is photographed and sent to the insurer as a supplement for approval before the work goes ahead. When we handle your claim, that conversation with the insurer is our job.

Do I still pay a deductible?

If you claim on your own collision coverage, your policy deductible usually applies. If the other driver was at fault and you claim on their insurance, you normally do not pay a deductible. Your policy has the exact terms.

Is there a cost for the estimate?

No. We give you a free estimate before any work starts.

What if I do not want to go through insurance at all?

That is your call. Some drivers pay for small repairs themselves to keep a claim off their record. A free estimate helps you decide which way makes more sense.

Claim open? Bring it to us.

646-347-5520

Open 24 hours.

Get a Free Estimate