Collision repair answers

Does car insurance cover hitting a deer?

Short answer

Usually yes, but under comprehensive coverage rather than collision. Most policies treat hitting an animal as a comprehensive claim, so you need comprehensive on the policy and you pay its deductible. If you swerve to miss the deer and hit a tree or another car instead, that is usually a collision claim.

Why it counts as comprehensive

Comprehensive coverage is for damage that does not come from crashing into another car or an object: theft, vandalism, falling branches, flood, and animals running into the road. Because a deer strike is treated as something you could not reasonably avoid, most insurers file it there. Many drivers carry a lower deductible on comprehensive than on collision, which works in your favor.

The catch is swerving. If you steer away from the deer and hit a guardrail, a tree or another car, the damage came from that collision, and it is usually handled under collision coverage instead. Safety advice generally says to brake firmly and stay in your lane rather than swerve.

If you only carry the minimum coverage required by law and no comprehensive, damage to your own car from a deer is usually not covered. For whether to keep the optional coverages on an older car, see should I have collision insurance on a 10 year old car.

Where deer strikes happen around New York

Deer are not just a country problem. Drivers on Long Island, on Staten Island and in Westchester meet them on wooded roads and parkways, most often at dawn and dusk and in the autumn.

What to do after hitting a deer

  1. Pull over safely and turn on your hazard lights.
  2. Stay away from the animal. An injured deer can kick hard.
  3. Call the police if the deer or the car is blocking the road, or anyone is hurt.
  4. Photograph the damage and the spot, including any hair or marks on the car that show what you hit.
  5. Check for leaks before driving on. A deer strike often hits the grille, and the radiator sits right behind it.
  6. Call your insurer to open a comprehensive claim, and ask whether a DMV report is needed in your case.

Damage that hides

A deer usually hits high and in the middle: the grille, the hood, a headlight and the bumper. Behind them are the radiator, the condenser, the hood latch and often radar sensors. A car can look drivable and still be leaking coolant. The bumper side of the claim is covered in is bumper replacement covered by insurance, and the whole process in our collision repair guide.