Most people go through a serious car repair only a few times in their life, so the process is new every time. This guide walks through it in the order it happens. It is written for drivers in New York City, Westchester and Long Island, but most of it holds anywhere.
At the scene: the first hour
What you do in the first hour shapes the whole claim, so it pays to be methodical even when you are shaken.
- Get safe. Turn on the hazard lights. If the cars can be moved and nobody is hurt, move them out of traffic.
- Call for help when it is needed. Call 911 if anyone is hurt, if a driver seems impaired, or if the road is blocked.
- Swap details. Names, phone numbers, plates, insurance company and policy number from every driver involved. Get the names of witnesses too.
- Photograph everything. Both cars from all four corners, close ups of the damage, the plates, the road, signs and traffic lights. Photos taken before anything moves are the best evidence you will ever have.
- Say little about fault. Be polite and stick to facts. Who pays is decided later by the insurers, not at the curb.
In New York you also have to file a report (form MV-104) with the DMV within 10 days if anyone was hurt or the damage to any one person's property is over $1,000. Then call your insurance company to open the claim. You can call a body shop the same day. Damage that looks cosmetic often is not, and a look over early gives you facts before the insurer's appraiser arrives.
Worth having before you call anyone
Collect these at the scene or the same day. They make the claim and the estimate faster for everyone.
The other driver's insurance
Company name and policy number, plus a photo of their insurance card if they will let you take one.
Plates and car details
Plate numbers, make, model and color of every car involved.
Photos of the damage
Wide shots and close ups, taken before the cars move if it is safe to stay put.
A police report number
If police came to the scene, ask how to get a copy of the report.
Witness contacts
A name and a phone number is enough. Witnesses are hard to find again later.
Your own notes
Time, place, weather, which way each car was going. Write them down while it is fresh.
What collision repair actually means
Collision repair is the work of putting a car back to its condition before a crash. That covers far more than a dent. It can reach the bumper reinforcement, the radiator support, the frame or unibody, the glass, the sensors in the bumpers and mirrors, and the paint. The page on what collision repair means goes through each layer.
People use "collision shop" and "body shop" almost interchangeably, and in practice the work overlaps heavily. The difference is mostly one of emphasis, explained in collision shop vs body shop. For a sense of what comes through the door most often, from bumper scuffs to rear end hits, see the most common auto body repairs.
The people doing the work have distinct jobs. An estimator writes up the damage, body technicians repair or replace the metal and plastic, frame work is measured against the maker's dimensions, and a painter matches and sprays the finish. The role of an auto body technician explains who does what. Crash damage often reaches mechanical parts too, such as the radiator, the cooling fans or a suspension arm, which is why people ask whether body shops can fix mechanical issues.
Who pays: the coverage behind the claim
Which policy pays depends on who caused the crash and what kind of damage it is. In broad terms:
- The other driver caused it. Their property damage liability coverage should pay for your repair. You can file with their insurer directly.
- You caused it, or nobody else is identified. Your own collision coverage pays, minus your deductible, if you carry it.
- It was not a crash with another car. A falling branch, flood water, vandalism, theft or an animal strike usually falls under comprehensive coverage instead.
The deductible is the part you pay yourself on your own coverage. When the other driver's insurer pays, there is usually no deductible for you, though fault disputes can slow that down.
Some of the most searched questions here are specific. A bumper is often the first thing to break, so whether bumper replacement is covered by insurance depends on how it broke. Deer strikes are common on Long Island, Staten Island and in Westchester, and whether car insurance covers hitting a deer has a less obvious answer than most people expect. If your car is getting older, it is worth asking whether you should keep collision coverage on a 10 year old car.
Our insurance claims page covers the claim from the shop's side, including your right to choose who fixes the car.
Choosing where the car goes
Your insurer may suggest a shop from its own list. You do not have to use it. You can pick your own shop, whatever the insurance list says, and the insurer still has to deal with the shop you choose.
What makes a good choice is less about the sign over the door and more about how the shop works. A written estimate before work starts, photos of the damage, a clear account of which parts are being used, and someone who answers the phone. Where is the best place to get my car repaired turns that into a checklist you can use on any shop.
Dealerships are the other option people weigh. Some have their own body shop, many send the work out, and an independent shop can follow the same factory repair procedures. Dealership vs body shop sets out the trade offs honestly.
The estimate, the supplement and the cost
The first estimate is written from what can be seen with the car in one piece. Once the bumper and trim come off, it is common to find hidden damage: a cracked bracket, a bent support, a broken sensor. The shop documents it with photos and sends a supplement to the insurer for approval. That is normal, and it is the main reason a first figure changes.
What a repair costs depends on the car, the parts, the labor, the paint and whether any driver assistance sensors need calibrating afterwards. Nobody can price a repair honestly from a description over the phone. How much collision repairs usually cost explains each of those factors and how to get a real number.
Payment timing confuses a lot of people, especially when an insurer is involved. Do you pay before or after collision repair explains how the money usually moves between you, the insurer and the shop.
From the crash to your keys
Every collision claim travels roughly this route. Knowing the stops makes it easier to see where yours is.
Scene
Safety, details, photos and a police report when needed.
Claim
You open the claim with your insurer or the other driver's.
Estimate
The shop writes up the visible damage and the repair plan.
Teardown
Panels come off, hidden damage is found and sent for approval.
Repair
Structure, panels, glass and paint, in that order.
Final check
Fit, finish, lights and sensors, then the car goes home.
Inside the shop: how the repair runs
A well run collision repair goes from the inside out. Structure comes first: if the frame or unibody has moved, it is measured and pulled back to the maker's dimensions before any outer panel is fitted. Then the body work: damaged panels are repaired where they can be and replaced where they cannot. Glass, lights, trim and sensors go back in.
Paint comes last. Factory paint fades a little with sun and age, so a new panel sprayed straight from the paint code can look off next to the old one. A careful painter tints the color to your car and blends it into the panels on either side so the repair disappears in daylight.
Modern cars add one more step. Cameras, radar and parking sensors live in bumpers, grilles, mirrors and the windshield. After a repair that disturbs them, they often need to be checked or calibrated so the safety systems see the road where they should.
How long the car is gone
There is no honest single answer, and any figure quoted before the car has been looked over is a guess. A scuffed bumper and a bent frame are different jobs, and most of the waiting is not the work itself: it is parts on order, the insurer's appraisal, and approval of any hidden damage found once the car is apart. How long it takes to repair collision damage explains what speeds a repair up and what slows it down.
If you need a car in the meantime, check whether your policy includes rental reimbursement, or whether the other driver's insurer will cover a rental while yours is in the shop.
Picking the car up: what to check
Before you drive away, take five minutes in good light:
- Look along the panels. The gaps around the hood, doors and trunk should be even on both sides.
- Check the color from a few angles. The repaired panel should match its neighbors in daylight, not only under shop lights.
- Open and close everything. Doors, hood, trunk and fuel door should open easily and shut cleanly.
- Look at the dashboard. No new warning lights. Parking sensors and cameras should work.
- Take a short drive. The car should track straight with the steering wheel centered, and there should be no new rattles or wind noise.
- Keep the paperwork. The final invoice and the list of parts used belong in your glovebox file.
If something is off, say so before you leave. It is far easier to sort out at the counter than weeks later.
One question,one straight answer.
Each of these has its own page with a short answer up top and the detail underneath.
- What does collision repair mean?
- What's the difference between a collision shop and a body shop?
- What are the most common auto body repairs?
- What is the role of an auto body technician?
- Can body shops fix mechanical issues?
- Where is the best place to get my car repaired?
- Is it better to go to a dealership for body work?
- How much do collision repairs usually cost?
- Do you pay before or after collision repair?
- How long does it take to repair collision damage?
- Is bumper replacement covered by insurance?
- Does car insurance cover hitting a deer?
- Should I have collision insurance on a 10 year old car?
Getting the repair started
If you are reading this after a crash, the next step is simple. Our collision repair page covers how we handle the job: a free estimate before any work starts, and we work with your insurance company and handle the claim for you. The shop is at 99-49 66th Ave in Forest Hills, Queens, and it is open 24 hours. Call or send us the details and we will take it from there.
Questions about your crash? Call now.
646-347-5520Open 24 hours.
Get a Free Estimate