Short answer
Three stage pearl whites are usually the hardest, with metallic silvers close behind. Pearl whites build their color from a see through mid coat, so the shade depends on how many coats go on. Silvers depend on how the metal flakes lie, so they can match face on and look wrong from an angle. Some deep reds are also difficult.
Three stage pearl white
A pearl white is not one layer of white paint. It is a solid white base, then a translucent mid coat carrying pearl, then clear coat on top. The color you see comes from light passing through the mid coat, bouncing off the base and coming back through the pearl.
That makes the finish depend on the number of mid coat passes. One pass too many or too few and the panel looks warmer, cooler, creamier or brighter than the one next to it. Painters often spray a series of test cards, each with a different number of mid coats, to find the one that matches the car. White also shows every small difference in a way darker colors hide.
Metallic silver and light metallics
Silver gets almost all of its look from aluminum flakes rather than pigment. When the flakes lie flat and even, the paint looks bright face on and darker from the side. When they lie at random angles, it looks grainier and flatter.
How the flakes lie depends on how the paint goes on: how wet each coat is, the air pressure, the distance from the panel and the speed of the spray gun. Two panels in exactly the same mix can look different if they were sprayed differently. A silver can match perfectly when you look straight at it and fall apart when you look along the side of the car. Light golds, champagnes and other light metallics behave the same way.
Reds and other tricky colors
- Deep and tri-coat reds. Some reds use a translucent tinted layer over a base, with the same coat counting problem as pearl white. Reds also fade noticeably in sun, so an older red car may be well off its original color.
- Color shifting paints. Paints that change hue as you walk around the car are very hard to reproduce on one panel.
- Matte finishes. There is no gloss to hide differences, and a matte panel cannot be polished to blend in.
- Faded paint of any color. A badly sun damaged roof or hood can make even an easy solid color hard to match, because the real color is no longer close to any formula.
Solid colors with no flakes, such as plain white, black or a non metallic red, are generally the most forgiving, though black shows every swirl and texture difference in the finish.
How a shop handles a hard color
The paint code is only the starting point. Where it is found, and why it is not the whole story, is covered in how do I find out the exact paint color of my car. For a difficult color, a careful painter usually:
- Pulls the variants of the code, not just the main formula.
- Sprays test cards, including step cards with different numbers of mid coats on pearls.
- Checks in daylight and from several angles, not only under shop lights.
- Blends the new color into the neighboring panels so no hard line forms between new and old.
- Matches the spray technique to the factory look, so the flakes lie the same way.
None of this is unusual, and it should all be on the estimate. More on how paint is built and why it changes is in our color matching guide.