Short answer
Usually yes, when insurance is paying. Hail dents lower resale value, show up at lease return, and cracked paint inside a dent can rust. If you skip the repair, a later claim on the same panels may be reduced. It makes less sense on an old car you own outright with light damage and a high deductible.
Reasons it usually pays to fix
- Value. A car covered in hail dents is worth noticeably less to a buyer or a dealer taking it in trade. The dents are obvious once the light hits the roof.
- Lease returns. Lease cars are inspected for dents when they go back, and hail damage left unrepaired is usually charged for.
- Rust. Where a hailstone cracked the paint, water reaches the metal. New York winters and road salt speed that up.
- The next storm. Insurers generally do not pay twice for the same damage. If you take a hail payment and do not repair, a later claim on the same panels may be reduced or questioned.
- Insurance is paying. If you have comprehensive coverage, the cost to you is usually your deductible, while the insurer pays the rest of the approved repair.
When it may not be worth it
Fixing is not automatic. It can make less sense when:
- The damage is light and below your deductible. A handful of small dents can cost less than the deductible, so there is no claim to make, and you would pay all of it yourself.
- The car is old and you plan to drive it into the ground. If resale does not matter and the paint is whole, cosmetic dents may not bother you.
- The car is a total loss. On an older car with heavy damage, the repair can come close to the car's value, and the insurer may pay out the value instead of a repair.
What sets the size of the repair, from dent count to glass and paint, is explained in how much does it typically cost to repair hail damage on a car.
Keeping the payment instead
If you own the car outright, the insurer may pay you directly, and you can often decide what to do with it. If there is a loan or lease, the lender or lease company is often named on the payment and usually expects the car to be repaired. Before you decide to keep the money and the dents, think about the points above: lower value, possible rust, and a reduced claim if hail hits the same panels again.
A middle path
You do not have to choose between everything and nothing. Damage that affects safety, like cracked glass and broken lights, should be fixed either way, and cracked paint should be sealed before it rusts. Can you still drive a car with hail damage covers which damage matters for driving. Because most hail dents come out with paintless repair, the factory finish stays on the car, which helps value as well. The whole picture after a storm is in our hail damage repair guide.